

Before scoring, define the conditions a provider must meet to be considered. Depending on the project, these may include a required technical capability, availability during a specific window, security or confidentiality controls, a delivery location, or acceptance of a particular contract process.




Treat these as gates, not bonus points. A proposal that misses a critical requirement should not rise to the top because it is inexpensive or especially polished. Ask your security, legal, procurement, and technical stakeholders to review requirements that fall within their remit.
Rate each criterion on a simple scale—for example, 1 = weak evidence, 3 = adequate, 5 = strong and specific evidence. Add a short note explaining the score. If some criteria matter more for this project, agree on their relative importance before reviewing proposals; do not change the rules after seeing a preferred bid.
Does the proposal address the reason for the project, or only repeat the feature list? Look for a clear explanation of the problem, the intended users, and how the provider would confirm that the work is delivering value.
Ask for examples that resemble your project in technology, operating context, or complexity. A logo list is not enough. Useful evidence explains what the team did, what constraints it faced, and what the prospective partner learned. Confirm references where appropriate and with permission.
Evaluate the people who would actually do the work—not only the senior person who presents the proposal. Check relevant skills, roles, availability, continuity, and how substitutions would be handled. A strong firm-level profile does not automatically mean the named team is the right fit.
Look for a sequence that makes sense: discovery, design or planning, implementation, testing, review, and handover where relevant. Are dependencies visible? Are milestones tied to outputs and acceptance? Does the plan explain how issues will be surfaced and resolved?
The provider should be able to explain how it will work within the controls that apply to your project. Consider data access, account management, confidentiality, ownership of deliverables, subcontracting, and any regulatory or contractual requirements. Have the right internal specialists validate the details; a proposal is not a substitute for legal or security review.
Assess how the proposed approach works with your current architecture, integrations, data, and operational constraints. Ask what the provider would preserve, replace, or connect—and what assumptions need a technical discovery session. Favor maintainable solutions over unexplained complexity.
Who is accountable day to day? How will decisions, risks, changes, and approvals be recorded? What documentation, training, or handover will your team need at the end? Clear ownership is especially important when several vendors or internal groups share delivery.
Compare the same scope, not just the headline price. Review assumptions, exclusions, rate or milestone structure, change handling, support, expenses, and payment triggers. Ask each provider to identify the conditions that could change the estimate. A transparent proposal may be easier to manage even if its initial figure is not the lowest.
A red flag is a prompt to ask a better question, not always a reason to reject a provider. Give the team a chance to clarify—and keep the answer in the evaluation record.
WorkWall is a marketplace for businesses, technology firms, and technology resources. It can be one channel for discovering potential partners and reviewing proposals. Use the same brief and scorecard for each option, and complete your normal commercial, technical, security, and legal checks before work begins.






Discover how Workday connects your data dots, helping you make faster, smarter decisions—without the spreadsheet chaos.

Say goodbye to outdated forecasts. Workday helps you embrace continuous planning to keep your finance team fast, flexible, and future-ready.

Transform your workplace vibe. See how Workday creates meaningful employee experiences that keep your top talent loyal and thriving.

Discover how Workday's automation capabilities enhance operational efficiency by reducing manual tasks and improving accuracy across workflows.

Discover how CIOs can lead the charge in digital transformation by utilizing Workday’s cloud-based solutions to enhance agility, innovation, and data-driven decision-making.

Learn how Workday helps organizations remain agile, adapting to changing business environments with real-time solutions and flexible processes

Explore how Workday’s contract intelligence tools are transforming contract management through AI, automation, and improved collaboration..

Explore how Workday’s learning and development solutions help organizations build a future-ready workforce by promoting continuous learning, upskilling, and talent development.
Stay ahead of the tech curve! Subscribe to our weekly newsletter for a curated dose of the latest industry insights, project highlights, and exclusive updates.